The teams with the five highest scores in the Small-School Division of NEAML are shown below.

Year	First place	Second Place	Third Place	Fourth Place	Fifth Place
2015	Worcester Academy, MA	Maine SSM	Mass Academy, MA	Marianapolis Prep, CT	Hopkins School, CT
2014	Worcester Academy, MA	Commonwealth School, MA	AMSA Charter	Maine SSM	Mass Academy, MA
2013	Worcester Academy, MA	Marianapolis Prep, CT	Mass Academy, MA	Commonwealth School, MA	AMSA Charter
2012	AMSA Charter, MA, and Marianapolis Prep, CT (tie)		Brunswick School, CT	Mass Academy, MA	Commonwealth School, MA
2011	Worcester Academy, MA	Hopkins School, CT	AMSA Charter, MA, and Brunswick School, CT (tie)		Marianapolis Prep, CT
2010	Hopkins School, CT	Worcester Academy, MA	Maine SSM and Marian, MA (tie)		Maimonides School, MA
					Pomfret School, CT
2009	Hopkins School, CT	Worcester Academy, MA	Wheeler School, RI	MacDuffie School, MA	Maimonides School, MA
2008	Hopkins School, CT	Worcester Academy, MA	Falmouth, ME	Maine SSM	Cheverus, ME
2007	Worcester Academy, MA	Hopkins School, CT	Wheeler School, RI	Falmouth, ME	Cheverus, ME
2006	Worcester Academy, MA	Maimonides School, MA	Wheeler School, RI	Hopkins School, CT	Brunswick School, CT
					Rocky Hill School, RI
2005	Hopkins School, CT	Worcester Academy, MA	Derryfield School, NH and Maimonides School, MA (tie)		Mass Academy, MA
2004	Hopkins School, CT	Bedford, MA and Derryfield School, NH (tie)		Brunswick School, CT	Pomfret School, CT*
2003	Hopkins School, CT	Weston, MA	Derryfield School, NH	Maimonides School, MA	Mattanawcook, ME
2002	Maine SSM	Hopkins School, CT	Derryfield School, NH and Pomfret School, CT* (tie)		Brunswick School, CT
2001	Hopkins School, CT	Maine SSM	Cheverus, ME	Swampscott, MA	Dover-Sherborn, MA
2000	Swampscott, MA	Hopkins School, CT	Maine SSM	Brunswick School, CT	Dover-Sherborn, MA
1999	Weston, MA	Deerfield Academy, MA	Pomfret School, CT	Maimonides School, MA and St. Paul's School, NH (tie)
1998	?	?	?	?	?
1997	Hopkins School, CT	Maimonides School, MA	Bromfield, MA	Worcester Academy, MA*	Oyster River, NH
1996	Hopkins School, CT	Maimonides School, MA	Dover-Sherborn, MA	Bromfield, MA	Brunswick School, CT
1995	Swampscott, MA	Worcester Academy, MA	Hopkins School, CT	Mattanawcook, ME	Winslow, ME
1994	Hopkins School, CT	Maimonides School, MA	Weston, MA	Swampscott, MA	Mass Academy, MA
1993	Maimonides School, MA	Worcester Academy, MA	Swampscott, MA	Deerfield Academy, MA*	East Greenwich, RI
1992	Worcester Academy, MA	Maimonides School, MA and Swampscott, MA (tie)		Hopkins School, CT	Winslow, ME
1991	Maimonides School, MA	Hopkins School, CT	Hollis Area, NH	Wheeler School, RI	Jay, ME
1990	Maimonides School, MA	Wheeler School, RI	Hopkins School, CT	Weston, MA	E. O. Smith, CT
					Westwood, MA
1989	Deerfield Academy, MA*	E. O. Smith, CT and Westwood, MA (tie)		Loomis Chaffee School, CT	Laconia, NH
1988	Maimonides School, MA	Hopkins School, CT	Suffield, CT	Weston, MA	Madison, ME
1987	Hopkins School, CT	Maimonides School, MA	Dover-Sherborn, MA	Wiscasset, ME	Weston, MA
1986	Maimonides School, MA	Hopkins School, CT	Old Rochester, MA	Suffield, CT	E. O. Smith, CT
1985	Maimonides School, MA	Hopkins School, CT	Laconia, NH	E. O. Smith, CT	Hamilton-Wenham, MA
1984	Maimonides School, MA	Hopkins School, CT	Weston, MA	Worcester Academy, MA	Laconia, NH
1983	Maimonides School, MA	Worcester Academy, MA	Hudson, MA	Laconia, NH	Moses Brown, RI
1982	Maimonides School, MA	Rumford, ME	Hamilton-Wenham, MA	Kingswood-Oxford, CT	Worcester Academy, MA
1981	?	?	?	?	?
1980	?	?	?	?	?
1979	?	?	?	?	?
1978	?	?	?	?	?
1977	?	?	?	?	?
1976	?	?	?	?	?
1975	?	?	?	?	?
1974	?	?	?	?	?
1973	?	?	?	?	?

* Prior to 2005, there was an assumed but unwritten rule that students who had already graduated from high school (or equivalent) were not eligible to compete at NEAML. Pomfret brought postgraduates to the championships in 2002 and 2004, Deerfield brought postgraduates to the championships in 1989 and 1993, and Worcester brought a postgraduate to the championship in 1997.